Hon. Michael E. Bortner

Judge Bortner's Average Overall Review:

1 Stars

Based on 4 reviews

  (717) 771-9705

  Unknown (fax)

  Unknown email address



1732. other

Cherylann Dowell and Christopher Armagost would be alive today if Judge Bortner had upheld his judicial responsibilities. In both these cases, and probably others, Judge Bortner failed to protect the community and put violent criminals behind bars. On May 21, 2012 Judge Bortner found Ross Crawford in violation of parole on convictions of terroristic threats, criminal mischief and harassment against Cherylann Dowell. Rather than put this repeat violent offender behind bars Judge Bortner released him to house arrest. Crawford murdered Cherylann Dowell 19 days later. On December 7, 2011 Anthony White was convicted by a jury of conspiracy and robbery. Judge Bortner released him on bail rather than sending him directly to jail. Anthony White murdered Christopher Armagost three day later. FACEBOOK: Vote No Judge Bortner


7775. party to case (with attorney)

This judge has a tenuous grasp on justice and law. It's unfortunate he still holds a seat in York. His decision was made on a whim and with little regard to the recommendations of all parties present. He's sad at best. Ruins lives at worst. Sad. One star, only because I'm unable to rate zero and he at least has a gavel.


466. party to case (with attorney)

I would not recomend placing my life in the hands of this man... He is bitter and not open-minded to facts presented. He fails to understand matters presented. His knowledge of the law was at best minimal. Having said these things, I do not believe him to be a bad man, but jaded.


8382. witness

I truly do not know how this Judge sleeps at night. He put a constant offender of probation and sentenced him to 11 months in prison (York County and he will only serve 8 months) for beating a 3 year old. The child was beat and bruised in the face and his private areas was bruise and of course the C&Y will not give an explanation or do they care. Perpetrator was given three charges and the one was aggravated assault and was later withdrawn, his Endangerment of a child was nolle prossed and the only thing he plead guilty to was simple assault which he has other simple assaults on record. I just don't see how justice was given to a three year old little boy who was innocent. Perpetrator's track record is pages of drug and alcohol abuse but put in the community so he can violate again or the next little victim may not be so lucky. I am so appalled by this decision. My rating is a big zero but I have to rate with at least one star or this website will not let me save my comment.

Review this Judge

This website is governed by the general rules of respectful civil discourse. You are fully responsible for everything that you post. Gavel Bangers does not control the content posted. Nevertheless, Gavel Bangers may monitor any user-generated content as it chooses and may remove content for any reason whatsoever, without consent. Disrespectful, profane, rambling, illiterate, and ALL CAPS comments will be deleted.